Activity Based Science Learning >Compare thermal conductivities of two metals


Objective:  To play with different materials and compare their thermal conductivities
Equipment:
Three metal cans, Rods of different materials but same geometry, small immersion heater, three thermometers 
Introduction:
Thermal conductivity of a material is one of the key factors which decides how much heat will pass through it if the two ends are maintained at different temperatures. For a cylindrical object, the equation governing the rate of heat flow is introduced in class 11 as

 where K is the thermal conductivity of the material, A is the area of cross section perpendicular to the heat flow, DT is the temperature difference across a length of DL along the heat flow. In the informal lab, the students can compare the thermal conductivities of different materials in a simple manner.
Procedure:

Suppose we wish to compare the conductivities of copper and steel. You have to procure a rod of each material. It could be say 10 cm long and 0.2 cm in radius. The dimensions are not crucial but two rods should be similar except for the material. The cross section also need not be circular.  Take three metal cans A, B and C. The cans A and C should be identical, B may or may not be identical to others.
Drill a hole in A and C and two holes in B. The holes should be such that the rods may be fitted in them and they should be at the same height from the bottom. Fit the copper rod between the cans A and B, and the steel rod between B and C. Close any gap between the rod and the can at the hole by an adhesive, say araldite.
Fill some water in the cans. The amount of water in A and C should be the same. The ends of the rods should be immersed in water. Put thermometers in A, B and C.  Put immersion heater in the can B and switch it on. Be careful, if the heater is faulty it can send electrical current in water and can. Do not touch anything when the switch it on.

In few minutes water in can B will start boiling. Read temperatures in all the cans. Steel is poorer conductor of heat as compared to copper. The temperature rise in A should be more than in B. By comparing the temperature rise in the two cans in a given time interval, you can have an estimate of the ratio of the thermal conductivities of the two materials.
Discussion:
The equation for heat flow given above may not be usable in the conditions described. There are losses to the atmosphere at every stage. That is why I insist on having all other conditions identical except the materials of the rod. If the student wishes he/she  may modify the procedure to get more accurate results.

Hazards:
As mentioned above, if the heater is faulty it can send electrical current in water and can. Do not touch anything when  the switch it on. 

When to do:
Class 11, after you have done thermal conductivity.

I
nstrument cost and availability :
About Rs. 100

 





 


Back on top ^