Interview with Dr. Derek Yach

Project Director
Tobacco Free Initiative
World Health Organisation
Tobacco free initiative

E-Mail -yachd@.who.int

I. Interview with Dr Derek Yach who was in India early January 2000

Comcom: Dr Yach , can you kindly elaborate on the Tobacco free initiative campaign

Dr. Yach : Well the tobacco free initiatives is one of the cabinet projects of World Health Organisation. The other one is called 'Drawback Malaria' and when Dr. Bruntlin , the Director General came into office she decided to tackle two major public health threats of global nature.

We were created specifically to take a stronger global approach to the whole problem of tobacco given the enormous global impact that it is having and particularly given the impact it will have in the developing countries over the next few years.

ComCom : What is the main issue of ?

DR. Yach : Well the main points here is to try and build the constituency in the developing world, of people who understand the legal and international approaches to tobacco control. We have people from international law , litigation, from the legislature and economists and public health people who are trying to say what are the best methods that we need to use at national level and at global level.

We find that at the national level medical approaches alone will do very little to improve the prospects of tobacco control. Rather what we need is a stronge excise tax and that requires economists. We need strong legislation to control stricly advertising and promotion which requires the service of legal profession. we need stronger support to stop people smoking in public places and in homes. Individual countries need to work together. We are discussing the development of the world's first public health treaty which could be international convention to tobacco control.

Some of the issues are: What are the possible contents of an international treaty to control tobacco? what are some of the issues that crossnational borders, smuggling , satellite television, internet , design of tobacco products, all these issues would be addressed. At the same time we will be looking at some hardened approach to tobacco control including the use of litigation to try and force the tobacco industry to make public the information about how they behaved in the past and what they were known and how they influenced the policy forces in the country.

This is particularly important in countries like India where you are starting to establish stronger pursuit to tobacco control.

ComCom : What about the role of media and ban on tobacco use?

Dr Yach : We must think and share from other countries which have acheived success; The key problem ofcourse is that while it is often easy to get legislation passed but tough to enforce it on the ground and the key to success lies in having strong community support and NGO activation well in advance of legislation.

So when the law comes out particularly banning smoking in public places it is the public the non smokers who demand the right to clean air You leave that really after the population,to force the smokers to abide by the legislation rather than putting the police force after go and arrest smokers.

Rather what we need for sustainable long term success is to ensure that smokers become more active passive smoking. Some of the conclusions that this conference is arriving at is try to reduce demand for tobacco through better tax and better legislation on the one hand and the concerns that the people have on the supply side, the role of farmers; the fact that many people are employed; we need to remember that the farmers involved in say the beedi industry or small scale farming are doing so not with any malice or any evil in the heart but beacuse they are simply trying to exist and have a livelihood.

What we are saying is that what we need to be thinking of for the future- new industries for the future and not trying to rebuild on the old industries based on tobacco. India is showing the revolution that is pouring in information technology. There is no reason why we shouldn't be thinking that many of the children of todays tobacco farmers couldn't find better livelihoods out of tobacco and in hightech industries than remaining with the industries of the twentieth century.


Interview with DR.S.P. Agarwal,
Director General of Health services,
India

II. Interview with DR.S.P. Agarwal

ComCom : Dr Agarwal kindly enlighten the situation regarding tobacco use in our country

DR. Agarwal : India is the second largest country in the whole world which has the maxiumum consumption of cigarettes including the beedis. The main substance is addictive in nature and once people start taking cigarettes they get addicted to nicotine.

Now there is enough scientific evidence that nicotine aand cigarette smoking and tobacco use is directly related to nearly 25 diseases. whether they are heart attacks or high blood pressures or strokes or cancers- diseases in which it is directly related to. If we have to reduce the disease burden it is important that the tobacco consumption is reduced. We have another problem of chewing tobacco the smokeless tobacco, that is chewing ghutka. It causes sub-mucosis fibrosis and it causes cancer.

But the whole problem of reduction of tobacco use is multi diciplinaray. Diiferent sectors are involved . You know a large number of people are involved in the production of tobacco, making of beedis and a number of other things. Number of other sectors will have to be taken into consideration and they have to work together. Raising of different crops for people who are growing tobacco,and also strategies need to be developed to reduce its consumption and thereby disease burden.

ComCom : What is the holistic approach to tackle this problem

DR. Agarwal : Now there is scientific evidence that passive smoking is a serious hazard. That means in an office environment or in a bus or in a place , where there are lot of non smokers, some people smoke and the other people who are non smoking are dangered by this passive smoking. So it is important that there are some areas which is smoke free and people will have a right to have clean air.

ComCom : As Director General of Health services kindly tell us the Indian Governments present approach to the problem?

DR. Agarwal : People should know that it is addictive and if we continue its use it can cause a number of diseases and will shorten the life span and quality of life. Secondly it is theuse of difference sectors like labourand agriculture, a joint approach towards its restriction can be achieved. Then of course is the problem of deaddiction - basically it is the awareness , basically it is the will power, which can make people reduce or leave the smoking. Connected Links for Further Reading :
Tobacco free initiative - I
Tobacco free initiative- II
Tobaco growers association WHO launches ground-breaking global anti-smoking campaign