|
Satyendranath bose along with meghnad saha, established
modern theoretical physics in india. Bose made significant advances
in statistical mechanics and quantum statistics, the description
of all forces by a single field theory, x-ray diffraction and the
interaction of electromagnetic waves with the ionosphere. In 1924
bose derived planck’s blackbody radiation law without the
use of classical electrodynamics as max karl ernst ludwig planck
(1854-1947) himself had done. Albert einstein’s generalization
of bose’s work led to the system of statistical quantum mechanics,
now known as bose-einstein statistics which describes particles
of integral spin, which may multiply occupy the same quantum state.
Such particles are now known as “bosons” after the name
of s. N. Bose. Bose’s name has become part and parcel of modern
physics. There is no other scientist whose name is so indissolubly
linked with einstein in all the textbooks of physics. ‘indeed
bose’s work stands out as one of the central columns supporting
the edifice of modern physics’. As partha ghose has stated,
“bose’s work stood at the transition between the `old
quantum theory’ of planck, bohr and einstein and the new quantum
mechanics of schrodinger, heisenberg, born, dirac and others.”
Bose was a rare combination of
kaleidoscopic versatility and evergreen vivacity. He made two important
contributions in mathematical physics one in his 20s and the other
in his fifties. In terms of number of publications (if we go by
the present trend where every scientist would tend to flaunt his
number of publications rather than their contents) his contribution
would appear to be hopelessly insignificant. He published only twenty-five
papers including the obituary note on einstein published in science
and culture. Out of these 25 papers 17 were single authored that
is by bose himself. He had certainly the ability to do more important
work in mathematical physics. But he did not do. Why? Bose alone
could have answered that. However, it does not mean that in the
intervening thirty years he did not do anything. He worked in as
diverse fields as chemistry, mineralogy, biology, soil science,
philosophy, archaeology, the fine arts, literature and languages.
Unfortunately in india bose’s name is not
so familiar. This is a reflection of sad state of indian science.
To quote g. Venkataraman: “the name of satyendranath bose
will live for ever in physics…unfortunately, most people in
india have never heard of him. I would not be surprised if most
of our scientists also do not know much about him, although they
might have heard his name. Indeed, i am prepared to bet that barring
a sprinkling of physicists (mostly theorists), many in our physics
community too are ignorant about bose. Even if they have heard of
him, it is quite likely that they are not aware of the significance
of his work.”
Satyendranath bose (or s. N. Bose, as he is mostly
known) was born on january 1, 1894 in kolkata (then calcutta). His
ancestral home was in the village bara jagulia in nadia district.
In the late 18th century, when kolkata was yet to emerge as metropolitan
city, nadia used to be the centre of cultural and intellectual activities
in bengal. The dialect of nadia was adopted as standard form of
bengali language. He was the eldest and only son of his parents,
surendranath bose and amodini bose. Bose had six sisters. His father,
surendranath worked in railways. Bose’s grandfather ambika
charan also held a government job. Bose started his primary school
education in the normal school, which was close to their home. Incidentally
this was the same school where rabindranath tagore spent a short
period. As the family moved to their own house in different location
bose’s school also changed. This time he was admitted in the
new indian school. He was again shifted to another school, the hindu
school. The mathematics teacher of the hindu school, upendra bakshi
was a legendary figure. Once bakshi gave bose 110 marks out of hundred
in a test examination. It was certainly a crazy behaviour because
you do not expect to get more marks than the specified maximum marks
allotted to a particular subject. So the headmaster asked for an
explanation. The unrepentant teacher replied: “satyen had
succeeded in the allotted time in correctly solving all the questions
without excluding any of the alternatives.” He passed the
entrance examination from the hindu school in 1909. In fact he stayed
one year more in the hindu school as he was due to sit for the entrance
examination in 1908. But just two days before the examination he
contracted chicken pox and so he could not appear for the examination.
Bose utilized the time by studying advanced mathematics and sanskrit
classics.
After passing the entrance examination he joined
the intermediate science course at the presidency college of kolkata.
Here his teachers included prafulla chandra ray(1861-1942) and jagadish
chandra bose (1858-1957) . He passed his intermediate examination
in 1911. It is interesting to note that he had physiology as his
fourth subject in isc examination and in which he scored 100 marks
out of hundred. In the bsc honours examination in mathematics, which
he passed in 1913, he stood first in order of merit. He passed the
msc examination in mixed mathematics (modern-day equivalent to applied
mathematics or mathematical physics). He not only stood first in
the examination but also created a new record in the history of
the calcutta university by securing ninety-two percent marks. Meghnad
saha stood second in both the examinations. Bose, and also saha,
joined the newly created university college of science as lecturer.
Their first appointments were in the department of applied mathematics
but after a year they got themselves transferred to the department
of physics. On their initial teaching assignments bose said: “we
took upon ourselves the teaching of postgraduate students. Saha
taught theory of heat and thermodynamics and spectroscopy in the
physics department and hydrostatics in the mathematics department.
I was more amphibious, teaching both physics and applied mathematics
quite regularly. On me fell the task of teaching general physics
and giving all entrants suitable introduction to mathematical physics,
teaching them differential equations, harmonic analysis etc. I also
taught elasticity and relativity in the mathematics department.”
Besides teaching, both bose and saha started doing
research. They did not have any laboratory facility. The only thing
they had was the library of the presidency college. Even there the
advanced books by the great masters were not available. Fortunately
for bose and saha one dr. Bruhl in the bengal engineering college
had many important books and they started borrowing from him. Dr.
Bruhl belonged to austria. On health ground he was advised to live
in a country with a warmer climate. That is how dr. Bruhl landed
at kolkata. Dr. Bruhl, who was trained as botanist, taught engineering
physics and run the laboratory in the bengal engineering college.
Bose’s first important contribution in theoretical
physics was a joint research paper with saha. The paper titled “on
the influence of the finite volume of molecules on the equation
of state”, was published in the philosophical magazine in
1918. The next year bose published two papers in the bulletin of
the calcutta mathematical society. One was on “the stress
equation of equilibrium” and the other “on horpolhod”.
Both these papers were on pure mathematics. In 1920 he again published
a joint paper with saha on the equation of state in the philosophical
magazine. This was followed by bose’s paper “on the
deduction of rydberg’s law from the quantum theory of spectral
emission” in 1920. This was also published in philosophical
magazine. Then there was no publication from bose for three years.
When the dacca university was founded in 1921,
bose moved there as reader in the department of physics. In a letter
written to his friend m. N. Saha, bose described the situation at
the dacca university: “…it has been well over a month
since i moved to your part of the country. Work has not yet started.
Your dacca college had quite a few things but due to utter neglect
they are in a bad way. Perhaps i need not elaborate. On the table
of the sahibs are scattered lots of nicol prisms, lens and eye-pieces.
It would require a lot of research to determine which one belongs
to which apparatus. We do suffer from lack of journals here, but
the authorities of the new university have promised to place order
for some of them alonwith their back numbers. Talk is going on about
having a separate science library.”
While teaching post-graduate students at the dhaka
university bose felt dissatisfied with the existing derivations
of plank’s radiation law. Inspired by discussion with saha,
bose developed a logically satisfactory derivation based entirely
on einstein’s photon concept. As in earlier cases he sent
his paper to the philosophical magazine but to his disappointment
this time his paper was turned down. Then he decided to send the
paper to albert einstein with a request to arrange its publication
in zeitschrift für physic. It was a bold decision. Bose’s
letter to einstein has become important document in the history
of science. Bose in his letter dated june 04, 1924 wrote:
“I have ventured to send you the accompanying
article for your perusal and opinion. I am anxious to know what
you think of it. You will see that I have tried to deduce the coefficient
8p v2/c3 in Plank’s Law independent of classical electrodynamics,
only assuming that the elementary regions in the phase-space has
the content h3. I do not know sufficient German to translate the
paper. If you think the paper worth publication I shall be grateful
if you arrange for its publication in Zeitschrift für Physic.
Though a complete stranger to you, I do not feel any hesitation
in making such a request. Because we are all your pupils though
profiting only by your teachings through your writings. I do not
know whether you still remember that somebody from Calcutta asked
your permission to translate your papers on Relativity in English.
You acceded to the request. The book has since published. I was
the one who translated your paper on Generalised Relativity.”
Einstein not only acknowledged the receipt of Bose’s
letter but also assured Bose that he would have it published as
he regarded it as an important contribution. Einstein himself translated
Bose’s paper into German and it was published in August 1924
issue of Zeitschrift für Physic under the heading “Plancksgesetz
Lichtquantenhypothese” (Its English title was “Planck’s
Law and Light Quantum Hypothesis”) with the following comment
of the translator: “Bose’s derivative of Plank’s
formula appears to me to be an important step forward. The method
used here gives also the quantum theory of an ideal gas, as I shall
show elsewhere.” This is how quantum statistics was born.
It may be noted here that statistical ideas entered physics through
the work of James
Clerk Maxwell (1831-79) and Ludwig
Eduard Boltzmann(1844-1906) on the kinetic theory of gases,
more than a century ago.
Einstein applied Bose’s method to give the
theory of the ideal quantum gas, and predicted the phenomenon of
Bose-Einstein condensation.
When Bose was trying to rederive Planck’s
Law he himself was not even aware that he would make a revolutionary
discovery. Planck’s Law had been known for well over twenty
years and there were a number of derivations including the one by
Einstein. Bose said to J. Mehra: “I had no idea that what
I had done was really novel. I thought that perhaps it was the way
of looking at the thing. I was not a statistician to the extent
of really knowing that I was doing something, which was really different
from what Boltzmann would have done from Boltzmann statistics. Instead
of thinking of the light quantum just as a particle, I talked about
these states. Somehow, this was the same question that Einstein
asked when I met him. How had I arrived at this method of deriving
Plank’s formula? Well, I recognized the contradictions in
the attempts of Planck and Einstein, and applied the statistics
in my own way, but I did not think that it was different from Boltzmann’s
statistics.” It may be noted that even Einstein could not
foresee the full potential and application possibilities of Bose’s
idea, which, along with its subsequent development by Fermi provided
the basis of categorizing the fundamental particles into two groups
–bosons after Bose and fermions after Fermi.
In early 1924 Bose applied for two years leave from the Dacca University
to enable him to go to Europe to familarise himself with latest
developments in his fields. He got the permission only after he
could show Einstein’s appreciative postcard to the Vice Chancellor
of the University. Thus Bose in one of his letters to Einstein wrote:
“Your first postcard came at a critical moment and it has
more than any other made this sojourn to Europe possible for me.”
Bose arrived in Europe in October 1924. He intended
to spend a few weeks in Paris before going to Berlin to meet Einstein.
He was more comfortable in French than in German. However, he ended
up in staying about a year in Paris. Explaining this Bose said to
Mehra: “I wanted to go abroad directly to Berlin but I did
not venture to go straight on because I was not sure of my knowledge
of German. I came out thinking that perhaps after a few weeks in
Paris I should be able to go to Berlin to see Einstein. However
two things happened:
i) Friends
ii) Letter of introduction to Langevin
My friends, who received me on arrival there, took
me to their boarding house, where they were staying. Then they all
insisted that I should stay there. Well I found it convenient to
be among friends.”
After reaching Paris he wrote to Einstein requesting
his permission to work with him and also for his opinion on his
second paper. Bose wrote:
“My heartfelt gratitude for taking trouble of translating
the paper yourself and publishing it. I just saw it in print before
I left India. I have also sent the middle of June a second paper
entitled, “Thermal equilibrium in Radiation Field in the presence
of Matter.”
I am rather anxious to know your opinion about
it, as I think it to be rather important. I don’t know whether
it will be possible also to have this paper published in Zeitschrift
für Physic.
I have been granted leave by my university for
2 years. I have arrived just a week ago in Paris. I don’t
know whether it will be possible for me to work under you in Germany.
I shall be glad, however, if you will grant me permission to work
under you, for it will mean for me the realization of a long-cherished
dream…”
While Einstein did not acknowledge the receipt
of Bose’s second paper but this time Einstein replied. In
his letter to Bose dated November 03, 1924, Einstein wrote: “Thank
you sincerely for your letter of 26 October. I am glad that I shall
have the opportunity soon of making your personal acquaintance.
Your papers have already appeared sometime ago. Unfortunately the
reprints have been sent to me instead of you. You may have them
at any time. I am not in agreement with your basic principle concerning
the probability of interaction between radiation and matter, and
have given the reasons in a remark which has appeared together with
your paper…We may discuss this together in detail when you
come here.” Bose was naturally disappointed by Einstein’s
comments on his second paper. However, he started thinking deeply
about the objections raised by Einstein. He informed Einstein that
he was attempting to answer Einstein’s criticism in the form
of a paper. In fact Bose had shown the manuscript to Paul
Langevin(1872-1946) in Paris, who thought it worth publishing.
However, the paper was never published.
At Paris, one of his friends, Prabodh Chandra Bagchi,
introduced Bose to Sylvian Levi, the well-known French Indologist,
who in turn gave Bose a letter of introduction to Paul Langevin.
Bose wanted to familarise himself with latest developments in theoretical
as well as experimental physics. Accordingly Bose thought that he
should learn radioactivity techniques from Marie
Curie(1867-1934) and something of X-ray spectroscopy from
Maurice de Broglie (1892-1967). Langevin, who suggested that Bose
should pursue the possibility of working in Curie’s laboratory,
gave him a letter of introduction to Curie. Accordingly Bose met
Curie. Although Curie recognised Bose’s genius but at the
beginning she was hesitant in admitting him in her laboratory as
she was not sure Bose’s knowledge in French. This was because
of earlier unhappy experience with an Indian student, who had no
knowledge in French. So she had given Bose a long lecture emphasising
the importance of knowing French. So after spending few months in
learning French Bose returned to Curie’s laboratory Bose and
where he made certain difficult measurements of piezoelectric effect.
However, Bose’s desire to learn techniques in radioactivity
remained unfulfilled. Though Bose had a good working knowledge in
French but he did not tell the same to Curie at their first meeting.
If he informed Curie about his knowledge of French she would have
accepted him as her research assistant. Throughout his life Bose
never tried to draw attention to himself. Those who did not understand
Bose’s nature explained it in other ways. For example William
A. Blampied thought that `Bose was terribly intimidated by most
Europeans.’ To support such conclusion Blampied cited the
following instances: “Although he (Bose) was in Paris with
Langevin while the latter was communicating with Einstein on de
Broglie’s thesis, there is no evidence that Bose ever
tried to impress upon Langevin his dream of working with Einstein.
Presumably Madame Curie would have accepted him as research assistant
had he been able to convince her that he knew sufficient French.
Yet he was either too polite or too frightened to interrupt he English
monologue by replying in French and thus (perhaps) convincing her.”
With a letter of introduction from Langevin, Bose met Broglie,
who readily allowed Bose to work with his chief assistant, Alexander
Dauvillier. At Broglie’s laboratory Bose not only learnt diverse
techniques of crystallography but also became interested in theoretical
aspects of crystal behaviour.
In October 1925 that is after spending about a
year, Bose proceeded to Berlin. He was anxious to meet Einstein.
But he had to wait several weeks before he could meet Einstein,
who was on his annual visit to Leyden. Bose did not work with Einstein
but his meeting with him was quite profitable. Einstein’s
letter of introduction enabled him to borrow books from the University
Library and attend the physics colloquium. With Einstein’s
help he could meet some of the topmost German scientists—
Fritz
Haber (1868-1934), Otto
Hahn
(1879-1968), Lise
Meitner (1878-1968), Walther
Bothe (1891-1957), Michael Polanyi, Max
von Laue (1879-1960), Walter Gordon(1893-1940), Paul Eugene
Wigner(1902- ) and others. He worked in X-ray crystallography in
Polanyi’s laboratory and got engaged in theoretical studies
with Gordon. He also frequently visited `Radioactivity’ laboratory
of Hahn and Meitner. Bose visited Gottingen and where he met Max
Born(1882-1970) and Erich
Huckel (1896-1980).
In the latter half of 1926 Bose returned to Dhaka.
Though he stayed nearly two years in Europe Bose did not publish
anything. His friends suggested that he should apply for the post
of Professor in the Physics Department of the Dacca University.
They also suggested that he should get a letter of recommendation
from Einstein. Einstein was little surprised at the request because
he thought Bose should naturally get the appointment. But he complied
with the request. Apparently Einstein’s recommendation letter
did not help Bose. The post was offered to D. M. Bose. However,
when D. M. Bose declined the offer Bose was appointed as Professor
and Head of the Department of Physics in 1927. At Dhaka he got engaged
in experimental physics. He initiated studies on crystal structures.
Perhaps such studies were undertaken for the first time in the country.
He took up the task of designing his own experimental equipment.
He designed and constructed X-ray diffraction cameras for rotation
and powder photography. He formulated a simple method for identifying
the indices of the plane of reflection of Laue photographs recorded
in cylindrical camera. He had a fascination for chemistry. So he
started doing research in organic chemistry. He studied the reactions
of p-acetyle-amino-benzene-sulphonazide with pyridine and he also
worked on the synthesis of some r-pyrone derivatives related to
Patulin. In his chemistry related work he was assisted by P. K.
Dutta. In 1938 Bose investigated the problem of total reflection
of radio waves in the ionosphere. It is said that it was M. N. Saha
who induced Bose to look into this problem. To quote one of Bose’s
colleagues Dr. Satish Ranjan Khastgir: “Prof. Saha had once
come to Dacca from Allahabad. He gave a lecture in the Physics Department.
He addressed a huge gathering at the Curzon Hall. Saha spoke these
problems relating to reflection of radio waves from the ionosphere
on which he was working. He asked his friend Bose to work out a
solution for an intricate problem like this. Appleton had given
three conditions for the reflection of radio waves, Saha introduced
a fourth one based on the hypotheses that there is no absorption
of radio waves in the ionosphere. But Saha knew himself that the
assumption was arbitrary. So he requested Prof. Bose in the open
meeting to give a general solution to the reflection problem. After
this lecture Satyendranath concentrated on the problem and finally
succeeded in finding a general solution.”
Bose returned to Kolkata in 1945 to become the Khaira Professor
of Physics in Calcutta University. During 1953-54 Bose published
five important papers on the Unified Field Theory. Although these
papers were quite important but they did not create a great stir
as earlier papers in 1924. He sent these papers to Einstein. Einstein
was not sure how precisely Bose’s solution was to be used
in physics and he discussed it in detail in one of his papers. Bose
wrote down his reply in detail and he was supposed to discuss it
personally with Einstein at Bonn on the occasion of the celebration
of the 50th anniversary of the discovery of the theory of relativity.
It did not happen. Einstein died in 1955. When Bose came to know
the death of his master (as Bose addressed Einstein in his letters
to Einstein) he was so overwhelmed with grief that he tore and threw
away the only copy of his important paper. And that was the end
of his work on the unified field theory,
He had set up a laboratory of Organic Chemistry
at the Department of Pure Physics at the University College of Science.
A group of research students under Bose’s leadership initiated
an extensive study of Indian clay minerals by X-rays, chemical analysis
and cation exchange technique. He also tried to synthesise emetine
and quinine but was forestalled by other foreign scientists. He
initiated a systematic search for germanium in Indian sulphide minerals.
Dr. Asima Chatterjee, a well-known Indian chemist, who worked with
Bose on the structure and stereochemistry of several alkaloids and
other inorganic substances said: “Work on inorganic complex
salts and clay minerals was another major contribution of Professor
Bose. A large number of samples of clays, shale and soil from different
parts of India were studied. X-ray diffraction methods and the differential
thermal analysis were employed in order to understand the atomic
structure of common clay minerals and the effect of the layer thickness
upon cation exchange. Since clays are poor reflectors of X-rays,
there is a tendency to choose small diameter cameras but in general
with small cameras important details of the power diagram may not
be resolved. As such, an adjustable flat-plate camera was designed
and used in this investigation. The differential thermal analyzer
used in the present investigation was constructed after the design
of Berkelheimer.
Very little work was done in India at the time
when this project was undertaken. As clays were formed under widely
varying environmental conditions the study of minerals from regions
still unexplored is important both for the purpose of verification
and for new information. With this object in view a differential
thermal analyzer and a micro-focus X-ray tube were designed at the
laboratory for the study of a number of Indian clays obtained from
a wide variety of sources and isolated from different types of soils.”
In 1956 Bose became the Vice Chancellor of the
Visva Bharati University at Shantiniketan founded by Rabindranath
Tagore. Bose was to start teaching of science. He was also to initiate
scientific research in the newly created University. It may be noted
here Tagore had dedicated his book Visva Parichay (Introduction
to the World of Science) to Bose. However, Bose was not welcomed
by the old-timers at Shantiniketan. Perhaps they thought that Bose’s
initiative would go against the established tradition of Visva Bharati.
Whatever might be the reasons for their disliking towards Bose’s
presence at Shantiniketan, Bose was quite disappointed and returned
to KolkaIt in 1958. It was in 1958 that he was elected Fellow of
the Royal Society of London. Bose should habe been elected long
back. In 1959 he was appointed as national Professor, a post he
held till his death
To most of the smaller minds, Bose represents an image of a genius--which
disliked hard work and wasted his energies in trivialities. This
is because Bose took almost thirty years after the publication of
the paper in 1924, which made him internationally known to publish
another important paper. But then physics was not the only thing
for Bose. Bose’s range of interests was unlimited. Bacon had
said: “I have taken all knowledge to be my province.”
This was equally true for Bose, though he himself might not have
declared it. In this context it is important to quote what B. M.
Udgaonkar had to say about Bose: “For smaller minds he had
become a drop-out. However, his keen, perspicuous and versatile
mind, trained in the method of physics and mathematics was allowing
itself to range over a variety of fields, including chemistry and
biology, soil science and mineralogy, philosophy and archaeology,
fine arts, literature and music. Then after thirty years, during
1953-55, at the age of sixty he performed a tour de force and published
some important papers in Unified Field Theory, showing that his
mathematical powers were still as keen as ever.”
Bose was an unconventional scientist. He detested any form of formal
dress. He would not even mind attending an international scientific
conference wearing a lungi around him. He was totally informal.
Anybody could enter his room just by pushing the door. An interesting
episode depicting Bose’s informal nature has been described
by Shantimay and Enakshi Chatterjee: “ Professor
P. A. M. Dirac had come to Calcutta along with his wife in
the mid-fifties. They were sharing the same car with Bose. Bose
let them have the back seat. The front seat, which Bose occupied
along with the driver, did not have much room; nevertheless Bose
asked some of his students to get in. Dirac, a little surprised,
asked if it wasn’t too crowded. Bose looked back and said
in his disarming fashion, `We believe in Bose statistics,’
Dirac explained to his wife, `In Bose statistics things crowded
together.’ But surprisingly enough Bose preferred not to talk
of his work except by way of joke.” Bose mostly worked out
his calculations on loose sheets of paper and he did not bother
to preserve them.
Bose was averse to anything that would publicise
his name. He did not attempt to get a PhD degree and so while doing
path-breaking work in science he remained a plain MSc. He enjoyed
all good things in life.
In meetings, conferences or in any public forums
Bose would often close his eyes and people would think that he had
fallen asleep. But he used to be alert all the time. To quote S.
D. Chatterjee: “The conscious and the unconscious appeared
to have a strange deep unity in his restless brain. At different
level of perception the legend curved out a superb figure of a giant
who was engagingly childlike and a man of supreme genius who was
entirely human. Often he appeared to be immersed in laziness, but
the somnolescence was full of alertness. Once presiding over a lecture
of Professor Niels Bohr at the Saha institute of Nuclear Physics,
he had closed his eyes and it seemed that he was asleep. But when
Professor Bohr hesitated before the blackboard and said ‘Perhaps
professor Bose can help me here’, he at once opened his eyes,
explained the mathematical point and seemed to revert to his unseeing
meditation. On another occasion, at the same venue, he was presiding
over a lecture by Professor
Frederic Joliot Curie. After introducing the speaker in English,
he closed his eyes as usual. But when Professor Joliot asked for
an interpreter to render his speech in French into English and none
came forward, Professor Bose opened his eyes, stood up and translated
Professor Joliot’s speech into chaste English sentence by
sentence.”
Bose loved music and fine arts. Commenting on Bose’s
love for fine arts and music, S. D. Chatterjee wrote: “His
(Bose’s) personality casts its spell of genius on the common
people. They regarded him as a living myth or legend. Often in informal
musical concerts, Bose, the connoisseur of classical music, would
close his eyes and seem to fall asleep, to everybody’s dismay.
But at the end, he would open his eyes and put extremely pertinent
questions to the performer. He was extremely fond of instrumental
music and played on the Esraj like a master. People have seen him
playing on his Esraj in a lonely corner of his home, with tears
rolling down his eyes. He also had an absorbing interest in fine
arts, and often discuss about the elegance of mural paintings with
maestros like Jamini Roy. Seldom did he decline to attend any musical
soitree, cultural function or art exhibition, when invited.”
Further Shantimay and Enakshi Chatterjee have written
that Bose played the flute too. They wrote: “ The fact that
he played the Esraj himself is well known. What is not so well known
is that he played the flute too. Music was one of his early loves
and his interests ranged from folk music to classical as well from
Indian to Western. When Professor Dhurjati Prasad Mukherjee was
writing his book on Indian music he received a number of helpful
suggestions from his friend Bose. Dhurjati Prasad used to say that
if Bose had not been a scientist he might have become a master musicologist.”
Bose was a great populariser of science. He strongly
felt that it was duty to present science to the common man in his
own language. For popularizing science Bose wrote in Bengali. This
is the reason why his contribution in popularizing science is not
known outside Bengal. It were largely Bose’s efforts which
led to the establishment of the Bangiya Bijnan Parishad (Science
Association of Bengal), a registered society with the sole objective
of promoting and popularizing science through the vernacular. The
Parishad was formally inaugurated on January 25, 1948. The circular
announcing the formation of the Parishad stated: “We need
science at every step, but our system of education does not prepare
us for it, so that we are not able to utilize science in our everyday
life. The main obstacle so far was a foreign language through which
education was being imparted. Today the ties have changed. New hopes
and aspiration are emerging. Now it is the duty and the responsibility
of our scientists to popularize science through the medium of our
scientists to popularize science through the medium of vernacular
and thus help to create a healthy scientific attitude among the
people. As a first step to this effort it has been resolved to form
a `Bangiya Bijnan Parishad’. It was mainly through the inspired
leadership of Professor Satyendranath Bose.” The Parishad
started a monthly magazine on popular science in Bengali, Jnan O
Bijnan (Knowledge and Science). As part of his attempt in popularizing
science through the vernacular Bose even started teaching Relativity
to post-graduate students in colloquial Bengali.
Bose died on February 04, 1974. As S. D. Chatterjee
has written, “With Professor Satyen Bose’s death an
era ended—an era of great men who created science in India.”
Bose was too precious for India. India has many scientists but it
woefully lacks great scientists. In the Centenary Edition of Chambers
Biographical Dictionary (1997), which has entries of over 17,500
detailed biographies, only the names of six scientists figure namely
J. C.
Bose. C. V. Raman, S. Ramanujan, S. N. Bose, M. N. Saha,
and Homi J. Bhabha. In Cambridge Dictionary of Scientists (2002)
this number is reduced to four, where J.C. Bose and H. J. Bhabha
do not figure and in the Dictionary of Scientists of the Oxford
University Press (1999) this number is five, where the name of Bhabha
does not figure. So there are only four Indian scientists namely
C. V. Raman, S. Ramanujan, S. N. Bose and M. N. Saha whose names
figure in all the three publications mentioned above. Can we hope
to add some few more names in these publications? Our younger generation
has a lot to learn from the lives of our great scientists like S.
N. Bose.
Today there is an institute at Kolkata named after Bose—the
S. N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences.
For Further Reading
- Satyendranath Bose by Santimaya Chatterjee & Enakshi
Chatterjee, National Book Trust, India, New Delhi, 1976.
- The Unconventional Scientist by Santimay Chatterjee and Enakshi
Chatterjee, Science Reporter, January 1994.
- An Ingenious Derivation by Partha Ghose, Science Reporter,
January 1994.
- Bose and His Statistics by G. Venkataraman, Universities
Press (India) Limited, Hyderabad, 1992.
- Satyendra Nath Bose by S. D. Chatterjee in Biographical Memoirs
of Fellows of the Indian National Science Academy (Vol.7), New
Delhi, 1983.
- Satyendranath Bose (1894-1974) by J. Mehra in Biographical
Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society (London), Vol.21, pp.118-154,
1975.
- A World of Bose Particles by E.C.G. Sudarshan, Science Today,
January 1974
- The Crisis of Science by Satyendranath Bose, Resonance, February
1996 (this an English translation Bose’s article published
in Bengali in August 1931 issue of Parichay. The article is
translated by Arnab Rai Chaudhuri)
- Bose-Einstein Condensation Observed by Rajaram Nityananda,
Resonance, February 1996.
- Some Eminent Indian Scientists by Jagjit Singh, Publications
Division, Government of India, 1965.
- Prof. S. N. Bose: 70th Birthday Homage by Prof. S. N. Bose
Seventieth Birthday Committee, Calcutta, 1964.
- Bosons – The Birds That Flock and Sing Together by
V.B. Kamble, Dream-2047, January 2002.
|